As private music teachers who work closely with beginner students every day, we totally get the excitement of starting guitar lessons. One of the first questions parents and students ask us is, “Should we buy a shiny new guitar before the first lesson?” While it might feel like a logical next step, we often advise against buying a new guitar right away—especially if you’re just getting started.
Here’s why slowing down that purchase can actually help your student learn faster and avoid frustration.
The Problem With Buying a New Guitar Too Soon
A brand-new guitar might look great in photos, but it doesn’t always serve beginners well. In fact, it can sometimes get in the way of good progress.
Here are the top reasons we suggest holding off:
1. Fit and Size Matter
The most important factor in early success is whether the guitar fits your student’s hands and body—not how shiny it is. If a guitar is too big, too heavy, or has action that’s too high (meaning the strings are far from the neck), it can make learning painful and discouraging.
2. Set-Up Quality Varies Widely
Many inexpensive new guitars—especially ones ordered online—aren’t properly set up to play well. This means they may come with tuning or intonation issues that even experienced players find annoying. A used guitar that’s already been adjusted or a teacher-approved rental can often provide better playability right away.
3. Your Child May Switch Instruments
Especially with younger students, it’s not uncommon for a child to start on guitar and later fall in love with a different instrument. Renting or borrowing early on gives you flexibility and saves money if interests change.
Better Options for Beginner Guitarists
If you’re not sure what to do instead of buying a new guitar, here are our favorite options:
-
Borrow from a friend or family member. Often someone you know has a guitar collecting dust in a closet.
-
Rent from a local music store. These guitars are usually well-maintained and sized appropriately.
-
Ask your teacher to help you find a used guitar. We love helping families choose great instruments that are affordable and easy to play.
For more tips, check out our post on how to prepare for your child’s first guitar lesson.
What to Look for When You Are Ready to Buy
When your teacher gives you the green light, here’s what matters most in a beginner guitar:
-
Proper size (½, ¾, or full depending on age/height)
-
Comfortable neck and string height
-
Solid tuning stability
-
Good tone at an affordable price
For trustworthy advice, we often refer families to Sweetwater’s beginner guitar buying guide—a reputable source that explains features clearly.
FAQ: Buying a New Guitar
Q: Should I buy a guitar before my child starts lessons?
Not necessarily. It’s better to wait until a teacher can help ensure the guitar fits your child and is easy to play.
Q: Can we use an old guitar from a family member?
Yes! Just be sure to have it checked out by your teacher or a technician. A quick tune-up might be all it needs.
Q: When is the right time to buy a new guitar?
After a few lessons, once we know the student is enjoying it and we’ve found the right size and features.
